Poor communication torpedoes a second national park
When planning a nature reserve, you have to engage in a subtle art of communication. This failed in the case of the projected Adula Park, as an ethnographic analysis has now proven.
-
- Alp Ampervreila in the proposed buffer zone (Picture: A. Michel)
There isn’t going to be a second national park in Switzerland any time soon. Eight out of 17 local authorities in the cantons of Ticino and Graubünden voted against the proposed Adula Park. This region encompasses a unique diversity of landscapes and ecosystems, from 397 to 2,402 metres above sea level, and it includes the Greina Plateau. Sixteen years of meticulous planning, discussion, debates and negotiations were undone in November 2016 when a local referendum turned down the project.
-
- Parc Adula Abstimmung
- Results of the referendum on Parc Adula, 27 November 2016, by commune.
Just why the project failed has now been investigated by Annina Helena Michel and André Bruggmann of the Department of Geography at the University of Zurich. Their data-gathering entailed ethnographic methods such as observations, conversations with the local population and interviews with all the main actors. When analysing their data, the researchers used both qualitative and quantitative methods in order to bolster the reliability of their results.
Michel and Bruggmann wanted to achieve a better understanding of the level of discussion between the protagonists, in order to be able to identify all the weak points in their communication. One striking aspect was the gap between science and politics. This meant that the politicians were unable to convince the affected population sufficiently that the park would have been advantageous to them. Planning a conservation area requires a subtle art of communication that takes everything into consideration, including the importance of different languages in the region, and how the local population views issues of nature conservation. To sum up: good communication should succeed in preventing rumours and misunderstandings. This study could show the way forward in how future projects might communicate with the public.
Michel, A. H. & Bruggmann, A. (2019): Conflicting Discourses: Understanding the Rejection of a Swiss National Park Project Using Data Analysis Triangulation. Mountain Research and Development 39(1): 24-36.
More news
- Grassland ecosystems become more resilient with age
- Which glaciers are the largest in the world?
- Unlocking Environmental Narratives
- Relationships to nature go both ways – care and attention for nature bring satisfaction and joy for Swiss Alpine farmers
- «Ober mal wett hürate?» oder die Geographie der Schweizerdeutschen Grammatik
- Diverse forests outyield monocultures
- Drought-exposure history improves recovery of grassland communities from subsequent drought
- Satellite monitoring of biodiversity moves within reach
- Gone with the wind? How small birds move to the wintering grounds
- Choose your own route!
- Improving soil health in tropical regions
- Climate and soil determine distribution of plant traits
- Getting the big picture of biodiversity
- Capturing mood and affective states via Twitter
- What If Our History Was Written In Our Grammar?
- Can large volcanic eruptions make glaciers great again?
- New model simulates the tsunamis caused by iceberg calving
- Deep forest soils produce greenhouse gases as temperatures climb
- Global glacier retreat has accelerated
- 1918 Pandemic Second Wave Had Fatal Consequences
- Earlier than expected
- Locked-in and living delta pathways in the Anthropocene
- Staying home for nightlife
- Directed Species Loss from Species-Rich Forests Strongly Decreases Productivity
- Daily Mobility for Healthy Aging
- Water Towers of the world ranked on vulnerability
- Himalayan lakes are exacerbating glacial melt
- Gaming for better data
- Black mystery in the Amazon River
- Find your way back with intelligent navigation systems
- The emotional entanglements of smartphones in the field
- From fires to oceans
- Ice on a stick in soil research
- Melting glaciers causing sea levels to rise at ever greater rates
- Do financial incentives motivate farmers to conserve land?
- How landscapes contribute to our well-being
- Ice-sheet growing from the base
- Charcoal: Major Missing Piece in the Global Carbon Cycle
- Extracting mobility patterns from Call Detail Records
- Mapping functional diversity of forests with remote sensing
- Unaccompanied minor asylum seekers - feelings of belonging in educational experiences
- The effect of anxiety and spatial abilities in route learning from maps
- Making Concessions at the Mining Frontier in Burkina Faso
- New method for analyzing tracking data enables better understanding of behavioral patterns of animals
- Who is responsible for negative effects of anthropogenic climate change?
- Glaciers in the Karakoram Mountains are in balance since the 1970s
- The mega-event syndrome
- Historically unprecedented global glacier decline in the early 21st century
- Variability and evolution of global land surface phenology
- A literature-based estimation of fire-derived organic matter in soils
- Neoliberal austerity and the marketisation of elderly care
- Institutional shopping for natural resource management in a protected area and indigenous territory in the Bolivian Amazon