The impact of Covid-19 from an economic geography perspective
In these strange times, many of us have made use of this situation of confinement to think, research and discuss about how the world will keep developing during and after the Covid-19 pandemic. At the Economic Geography unit, we put together some thoughts on the current crisis and the resulting socio-economic one which is yet to arrive with full force.
-
- Image: Xavier Balaguer Rasillo
As economic geographers we are concerned with issues such as neoliberalism and marketization, commodity chains, gender, care work, alternative economies and digital labor. All these elements have already changed greatly. In these last few weeks and in the upcoming months we have seen and will very likely see changes in social, health and economic policy that usually would take place over decades. The very fabric of society is rapidly changing and things are not likely to go "back to normal". A new world is being born, and this implies shifts in power of which we should all be conscious. The narratives and debates which will define the next decade are already taking place. With this blog entry, we want to raise some issues related to our research fields.
In general, we observe that Covid-19 exposes some of the contradictions inherent to the hyper-globalized economic system. We are seeing how Covid-19 and the confinement rules are affecting people unequally. Once again people of color, women, migrants and the poor are being disproportionately affected by this crisis. Yet at the same time, it seems that this global pandemic is much more variegated in its effects, also seriously putting at risk large parts of the middle class, shop owners, small and medium-sized enterprises, for instance.
With regard to our research fields, we invite civil society, social movements, private and public enterprise as well as policy-makers to be aware and considerate of the following:
Work, Labour and Precarity
Care work
The public is currently praising the importance of care work. However, this recognition has so far remained mostly symbolic. We are even seeing an increasing precarization of care workers' living and working conditions in many fields. Taking the example of transnationally organised live-in home care for the elderly, we currently find workers who have to look after an elderly person around the clock for weeks on end, because their replacements fail in the crisis. Furthermore, we see migrant care workers stuck in their home countries without any financial means, because they are left out of the financial crisis support measures of the Swiss state. In crisis, the inequalities and the fragility of a care model that relies on transnational wage differentials and precarious working conditions becomes more obvious than ever.
For more on live-in care workers under corona:
Grenzerfahrungen in der Betreuung von Betagten, WOZ, 7. Mai 2020
For a situation analysis including Germany & Austria:
Impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on live-in care workers in Germany, Austria, and Switzerland. Blog of the International Long-Term Care Policy Network, 14 May, 2020
Agriculture and food systems
The Covid-19 crisis also risks exacerbating the existing inequalities and exploitation of agricultural labourers, who are mostly seasonal migrant workers. They have to work more intensively, including not taking scheduled vacations, while typically being left in the dark about their rights and financial protections in the event of illness or accident. The Covid-19 crisis therefore exacerbates existing problems while adding new economic, social and health challenges for migrant agricultural workers. As a news headline bluntly puts it , "the harvest is safe - only the harvest workers are not". In sum, we can observe that rich countries like Switzerland have the privilege of a quite steady food supply in the time of Covid-19, whereas less privileged places and people experience extreme food shortages and increasingly precarious lives as agricultural workers.
For a more detailed analysis: Widerstand am Tellerrand
Die Ernte ist sicher - nur die Erntehelfer nicht. Das Erste | Panorama, 23.04.2020
-
- Image: Unsplash / Ross Sneddon
Gig-Economy and Temporary Work
The effects of Covid-19 and related restrictions on the gig economy do lead, on the one hand, to a "digitalization" of new sectors and tasks (e.g. agriculture). On the other hand, a lot of the intermediated employment opportunities cease, because the service is no longer needed. This has existential consequences for the workers involved. The working arrangements, which are characterized by flexibility, instability and short-term contracts, typically offer no guaranteed employment and therefore no guaranteed income for the workers. If there is no gig, there is no income. Even though there are Covid-specific regulations for temp workers, it remains unlikely that gig workers would profit from these legislations. This results in increasing levels of precarity.
A Post-Neoliberal world?
A world in chains
Ever-expanding supply chains, production networks and logistical arrangements have become the hallmark of a globalized economy that thrives on a clever mobilization of borders: allowing almost frictionless mobility while simultaneously exploiting regional differences. Covid-19 has brutally exposed the contradictions and the asymmetric interdependencies of our b/ordered global economy. Soon after news about the first cases emerged from China, large parts of global commodity movements became immobilized. This also includes our research field of agricultural commodities and inputs. Chinese demand for soybeans and soybean meal, for instance, has been seriously affected, leaving farmers in Argentina, Brazil and the US to wonder about their economic livelihoods. And since China is also the key source of cheap input commodities such as glyphosate, the collapse of Chinese generic production and price increases will only further squeeze farmers' incomes globally. While the reprieve for nature will only be shortlived, there is an urgent need to rethink a food system built around "global soy" and its uneven chemical geographies.
-
- Image: Unsplash / Rinson Chory
Austerity, neoliberalization and housing
Recent weeks have seen an increase in financial rescue packages being issued by governments and central banks in many countries across the globe. There is reason to believe that, similar to during the aftermath of the financial crisis in 2008, many states will resort to even stricter austerity measures, privatization and market-oriented regulations to tackle high levels of indebtedness. In the United Kingdom, for instance, welfare services such as the National Health Service (NHS) have already come under immense strain as well as other services and charities supporting vulnerable people. For the homeless in particular this combination of reduced support infrastructures and already existing housing and job crises proves to be fatal, as this Guardian commenter notes.
Alternative Futures?
Potentials for an alternative future?
The crisis-related experiences of temporary workers in care, agriculture, the gig economy and other sectors bring to the fore existing labour-related inequalities. Moreover, they illuminate the paradoxes concerning the value ascribed to different types of labour in the capitalist system. This is particularly observable for workers who carry out social reproduction tasks, such as producing food, cleaning or caring, whose societal contributions otherwise often remain invisible. While many of these jobs are now considered to represent essential economic activities, they are still largely characterized by low wages, limited benefits, insufficient safety conditions and little job security. In order to contest the urge to "go back to normal", we need actions of solidarity that go beyond applause from balconies and demand a more radical re-evaluation of social reproductive labour.
Social movements and alternatives
This situation also poses challenges for social movements and the self-organization of workers and unions due to social distancing measures. Yet many movements and organizations remain active online and new forms of activism alongside technologies are emerging. The shift to online activism holds potential, but also faces challenges, particularly for those movements facing repressive governments. The internet and technological tools will become ever more important as sites of contestation, resistance and generation of alternatives.
A call to action
Up until now, we have only caught first glimpses of the changes happening in our research fields. More research is needed in the months to come to assess the longer-term effects of the current crisis. However, we already see now that a call for global solidarity and collaboration becomes imperative. By drawing attention to these issues in this brief blog entry, we want to encourage other scholars to join us in collectively shaping the narratives, exposing the inequalities resulting from this situation and finding solutions that move away from going back to an alleged normality. There was a societal and environmental crisis going on before Covid-19 and it will become more acute in the months to come. Therefore, we as critical researchers need to collaborate in critically analyzing the situation, engaging with the public debates and offering alternative views and practices.
More news
- The 125th and last
- Gletscher vor 125 Jahren und heute
- Ist das Navi in der Hand der erste Schritt zum betreuten Wohnen?
- Catapulted into a new world
- How to make health care service provision more equitable and greener
- Our world is a multidimensional collage
- Is Tourism the Beginning or the End? Livelihoods of Georgian Mountain People at Stake
- «Wir müssen den Klimawandel systematisch als Risiko mitdenken»
- Andean mountain regions: Fragile sentinels of landscape and cultural transformation
- Temporary streams at the doorsteps of Irchel Campus
- Counting snowflakes from space
- Provokation und Revolte am GIUZ
- Ambitious goals for biodiversity urgently needed!
- "The Eyes Have It!" - Where we look while navigating
- Investigating plants genetic structure from above
- «I see and I remember. I do and I understand.»
- «Für uns, unsere Kinder und Kindeskinder»
- Was macht die Digitalisierung mit unserer Umwelt?
- The role of a developer at GIUZ
- Dem unterirdischen Wasser auf der Spur
- Was der Geographieunterricht zur Bildung im 21. Jahrhundert beitragen kann
- Nepal - Kein Land für alte Leute?
- Klimawandel in der Schweiz: Alles, was du wissen musst!
- Wie Instagram unseren Umgang mit der Natur verändert
- Numbed by navigation technologies: How can we counteract?
- This is blog post number 100
- Investigating food sustainability: from production and trade to consumption
- Geographers live in concert - postponed!
- Global Glyphosate: Uneven Geographies of herbicide production and use
- "Pesticides burned grass and know-how"
- Vier Standorte in 125 Jahren
- Dietikon: Vom Bauerndorf zur Stadt
- What is biodiversity?
- Fieldwork in rural Nepal: reflection on positionality, responsibility, and roles
- Das Schulfach Geographie: heute und morgen
- Mapping functional diversity from space
- Adieu ewig’ Eis
- Landschaftsleistungen erlebbar machen
- What is the role of variability in nature?
- The Skin of Chitwan
- Animated flight line collection over Switzerland
- Space, Nature & Society: Wo wir forschen und was wir tun
- Do you know about the 3MT competition?
- An academic career in ecology
- Hundreds of students enrich the start of the semester at the University of Zurich
- Wie bewegen wir uns in Zukunft fort?
- Willkommen im GEO- und ESS-Studium!
- Expeditions from the window: How do you perceive your surroundings?
- Researching a pandemic - during a pandemic
- Das Geoteam stellt sich vor
- How roots influence climate change
- Imaging the earth from above
- Studierende sammeln Daten: Natur, Landschaft und Ressourcen
- Trouvaillen aus dem Archiv
- The fluorescence of phytoplankton from 800 km above
- Der kalte Norden ist auch familiär
- How the COVID-19 pandemic is teaching us to tackle the climate crisis
- Studierende sammeln Daten: Migration, Mobilität und Stadt
- Summer break!
- On the art of failing forward
- Die Wasserstadt Zürich mit dem Smartphone entdecken
- Tracing the tracks of the first Swiss polar explorers
- Geistreiche Wortspiele
- Von Gemüse über Milch bis zu Kaffee: Solawis in der Deutschschweiz
- Berner Seeland - quo vadis?
- Intense days on the field course to Val Piora
- Panta rhei - everything flows
- Comic Strip Geographies
- Where we come from
- A journey through time with loess deposits
- Schlacht am Morgarten 1315: Wie sah die Landschaft damals aus?
- Berne going green
- Biochar increases rice root architecture
- Cycling and pedestrian travel in Covid-19 world
- Why do we create virtual forests?
- Wenn das Eis fehlt: Das Lötschental und seine Zukunft
- Planning ski tours: insights from Big Data
- Is there a place for people in protected areas?
- Biodiversity in Irchel park
- Cress, tomatoes and the meaning of the universe
- Scientific games to understand social-ecological system dynamics
- Insight into the WGMS
- Connecting female hydrologists worldwide: an initiative born at GIUZ
- Shopping with Maximilian
- Sars-CoV-2 and food producers: who cares?
- The value of water
- Mit Slimy-Masse die Gletscherschmelze illustrieren
- Was machen Geographinnen und Geographen nach dem Studium?
- Geographie-Student Jonathan, der Erdball und die CO2-Männli
- Two study programs at the Department of Geography
- Urban Sustainability as New Financial Fix?
- Silently in the background
- Interaktiv und interdisziplinär
- Unpacking the complexity of social-ecological systems
- Listen to the landscape
- Creating synergies between homeschooling and university teaching
- The first fully remote PhD defenses
- Der Weltwassertag fällt ins Wasser
- The GIUZ Sustainability Task Force
- What is geography?
- «Geografe nüme schlafe!»
- Zurich on its way to the 2000-Watt society
- Spatial genetics for plant-based communities - and much more!
- Strebergärtli - Irchel Garden Project
- Writing papers - a nightmare. Or not?
- Urbanised landscapes - living between nature and civilisation
- A 3D view on breathing forests
- «Wir sind hier, wir sind laut!»
- What is EGEA?
- Exploring the future of biodiversity
- Avalanche bulletins in the Alps: consistency across borders
- Ice age coffee
- Greenland 1912 - and today!
- «Wir sitzen alle im selben Boot»
- Air miles monitoring & reduction @ GIUZ
- The "Geographie Alumni UZH" society: a platform for people interested in Geography
- Knowledge in images - information design today
- Geographie in Aufruhr
- Glacier measurement series with mayonnaise
- Landkarten im Reduit
- Mapping the plastic soup
- New unit "Space, Nature and Society"
- How it all began
- Happy 125th Anniversary